"He is good at writing kids and adolescents" admit the detractors...
Having just read Catcher In The Rye and seeing what all the fuss was about (I think) I then went on to read as much Lit Crit about it as I could stand. I was just surprised, like, maybe even depressed, by how many people seem to miss the point - so many phoneys out there etc. I could go on in parody but it was done better at the time by another reviewer.
I think it WAS the novel of the C.20 as Mark Twain might've been before (haven't read that). I think what made it so good was that I am still thinking about it. What else made it so good? It's just agonising reading the memoir of a kid who thinks of himself, is thought of by his co-players in the book and mostly, by the reviewers (til I gave up, which wasn't long) as an adult, when in fact he is still a kid. Holden himself says so repeatedly, during a mostly painfully accurate and acute assessment of human nature, human development and character and is always disagreed with. He (Salinger) understands what it is to be an adolescent and be more insightful (it's a liminal space and I am trying not to over-use parentheses) than children or adults usually are.
The simple agony of the book is the beautifully realised imagining of acute loneliness felt by a little boy lost, who everyone thinks should be mature, while none of them are and while we see that 'immaturity' grow out of sane and consistently fair judgements. We can read the book as adults and obviously, we can re-assure ourselves that we do have adult advice for Holden. But how would that help?
There was one very good quote I read in the reviews. Mr Antolini would've got it - I think (see how I'm slipping into Holden without even trying?). I'll go look for it. The crux of the whole ting is whether you think Antolini was just a 'perv', was a 'perv' but was still caring and all the things Holden hoped he was - or was, in fact not a perv and was still all the things Holden hoped he was, which it is just possible could've been true had Holden not had such bad experiences which had stopped him from allowing himself to discover this fictional and yet most hopeful of facts.
Whatever. I blame the parents...
The quote was: " - " nah, can't find it. Was good tho.